01773nas a2200181   4500008004100000245006900041210006800110260001200178490001500190520118600205100002501391700002201416700002001438700002001458700002301478700002001501856007001521       1993                        eng d00aPhase I Results of the NFRC U-Value Procedure Validation Project0 aPhase I Results of the NFRC UValue Procedure Validation Project  c08/19930 v100, Pt. 13 a<p>The NFRC U-Value Procedure Validation Project was undertaken by a collaborative group of industry, public utility, trade associations, and government researchers in order to validate the testing and calculational methods of the NFRC 100-91: Procedure for Determining Fenestration Product Thermal Properties (Currently Limited to U-Values). This paper summarizes the validation projects goals and test methodology, the results of the data analysis, and the recommendations following completion of Phase I of the project. Simulations performed according to NFRC 100-91 are shown to agree with each other, to within the NFRC tolerance, in 100% of the cases. Window test results with perpendicular wind performed according to NFRC 100-91 are shown to agree with each other, to within the NFRC tolerance, in 84% of the cases. Simulations and perpendicular wind window test results are shown to agree with each other, to within the NFRC tolerance, in 80% of the cases. Testing of skylights was shown to be problematic under the procedure as written at the time. Agreement between tests and simulations will improve as a result of a strong NFRC education and accreditation program.</p>1 aArasteh, Dariush, K.1 aBeck, Fredric, A.1 aStone, Nehemiah1 aDuPont, William1 aMathis, Christophe1 aKoenig, Michael  uhttps://facades.lbl.gov/publications/phase-i-results-nfrc-u-value